The Bluesky exchange about business Instagram posts did what good arguments do: it made both sides feel correct and neither side feel satisfied [1]. The person defending AI generation had the cleaner logic — business accounts are not personal diaries, efficiency is real, and scale is a legitimate professional goal. The person objecting held a degree in the relevant field and still could not land a disqualifying counter-argument. What they were defending was not a rule but a value, and values lose to efficiency claims in professional contexts unless someone…